Not That I’ve Ever Worked 40 Hours
It’s my opinion from limited, but not undiverse, observation that at public teaching hospitals resident physicians are burdened with an unnecessary number of mundane calls and often at inapropriate times. This compared to the private world.
I’m not sure why there needs to be a 11pm call for a potassium of 3.7 or a 2am call that there is no order for incentive spirometry. Not that such inappropriately timed communication is limited to nursing staff. I’m not sure why a resident (or staff) radiologist needs to call the ordering physician at midnight that an NG tube is in the esophagus. Nor am I excused here. I’m not sure I need to call the medicine consult service at 10pm for asymptomatic hypertension.
It seems sometimes that individuals within teaching facilities operate with very poor levels of discretion and independence and just plain commonsense.
My residency program rotates through my faculty’s private practice at a facility with no other residents. Similiarly my wife started at a community program where her residency was the only training program within the system. The norm in these private institutions is far fewer of such calls in my experience. Not that they don’t happen, just that they’re with much, much less frequency. Instead you arrive in the ICU for morning rounds and the nurse informs you, “The patient’s nausea was well controlled and she passed her bedside swallow last night so I pulled her NG tube and advanced her diet. Can you sign those orders in the chart?”
There is something in the culture or training of public teaching hospitals which apparently encourages everyone to run everything by everyone else. There is limited initiative and limited recognition of which issues need to be tertiarized to someone higher up.
I think the fact these institutions are places of training, and not just physicians but nurses and other providers, makes for more calls as people learn. I think the fact more providers take call in house at large public hospitals encourages calls as there is an attitude that the resident physicians are already working and so there is hassle to calling. I think the fact that these hospitals take care of sicker patients, who probably require more calls in general, encourages frivolous calls. And I do think that the fact it is residents, and not private physicians, who are being called also lowers the threshold at which calls are made somewhat.
Now to be fair my exposure to large public teahcing facilities outside my own is limited. I have some at rotations as a medical student and remember residents at those places getting plenty of inappropriately timed calls but perhaps my experience isn’t representative. I’d be interested in hearing from those who have been at other places.
This issue isn’t merely a matter of resident lifestyle; although it is such. This is a patient care matter. A call from a radiologist about a malpositioned Donhoff tube probably shouldn’t go from the radiologist to the ordering physician to the nurse, it should go from the radiologist to the nurse who understands the correct position and advances the tube of his own initiative. Increasing the relays of information is usually poor design, no less in health care. Nurses and RTs and other providers who can correctly tertiarize issues and provide appropriate care to patients on the spot obviously represents a better model and better patient care than waiting for a verbal order, from a scatterbrained resident in the middle of the night.